Next Monday is Columbus Day, the annual commemoration of the
discovery of the Americas by Christopher Columbus on October 12, 1492. It is a
government holiday, so banks will be closed and the post office will not
deliver your mail. Most government offices will be shut down for the day in
honor of the great discoverer. He was a great discoverer, wasn’t he? It seems
these days, it depends upon whom you ask.
It has been 532 years since he and his crew sailed the Niña,
Pinta and the Santa Maria to the shores of the Bahamas. Today, Columbus’
reputation as a great discoverer is a matter of opinion. First, he was misguided
in his calculations as a sailor. He was sent to find a shortcut to Asia. He was
trying to sail to Japan when he discovered the islands of the Caribbean, which
he insisted were the East Indies (thus the reason he called the indigenous
people living there "Indians.”) Columbus traveled from Europe to the Americas
four different times, but never admitted that he was in a new continent, always
insisting he was in Asia. However, the bigger controversy these days has
nothing to do with his ineptitude as a sailor, but his initiation of European greed
that brought a rash of colonization, slavery, disease and genocide. Four years
ago, a Christopher Columbus statue in Richmond, Virginian was toppled, spray
painted, burnt and thrown into a pond. It appears that Columbus has become the
poster boy for revisionist historians’ hatred of anything that they deem
"hateful.” On the flip side, a group in Blauvelt, NY paid to have the statue
restored and today it is housed in the Sons of Italy Lodge.
All that may be too much to hang on Christopher Columbus. He
was looking for a gold and spice route to Eastern Asia and ended up with a
Caribbean cruise. Yet, there are cities throughout the U.S. that are refusing
to recognize Columbus Day next Monday. Some have renamed it Indigenous People
Day or Discovers Day. Whatever you call it, Columbus’ reputation has taken a
hit. He used to be one of the most celebrated of the discoverers (bear in mind
that every state in the Union has at least one city, county or district named
for him.)
What are we to make of this type of reversal of history?
Keep in mind that it is the job of marketing to guard the reputation of your
brand. Public opinion can sway against you quickly these days. Make sure you
are aware of what is being said about you, particularly on social media. Also
be careful who and what you associate with in your company. Celebrity
endorsements can go awry when your endorser says or does something stupid.
Trying to appeal to a demographic that is not in your target market can cause all
kinds of problems for you… go ask Bud Lite. Trust, but verify. Finally, keep in
mind that there are groups of people who will glob onto anything that looks
like they are taking down a business. It is an oddity of our current society.
Historically, there has been rage that has spilled over against large
corporations. Today’s social activist doesn’t seem to care if your business is
large or small. They want to disparage any business. Be wary of them.
Also keep in mind that for every town crier that posts on
social media, there are countless people who don’t. In fact, there has been a
backlash against all the venom that is spewed online. What do your customers
think? It is very important for you to know and understand what they are
thinking, what they believe and what they value. Your marketing needs to
intrigue them without insulting them. The only way you can do that is to know
what they are thinking and where their parameters are for good and bad tastes.
Your marketing should mirror their beliefs.
Columbus might not be the
same man of reputation that he was in years past. Then again, maybe he is, or
maybe no one really cares. Just keep in mind that if the people you are trying
to sell your products and services to are turned one way or the other, your
marketing should sail with them. And if they are indifferent, pay no attention
to the rhetoric surrounding revisionism.